As in many other things, there are debates as well as other viewpoints. However, step 1 argue that the brand new Swedish government and you may secret actors need understand the needs of the newest sex workers that really work in the the world alternatively ot providing they all are sufferers from the early in the day traumas who want as rescued.
Danna, D. (2014). Article on prostitution rules throughout the Eu. Milan: The University of Milan. Garofalo Geymonat, G. (2014). Vendere e comprare sesso: Time piacere, lavoro eprevaricazione. Bologna: II Mulino. Holmstrom, C., Skilbrei, M. L. (2017). The Swedish sex purchase act: Where does it stand? Oslo Law Remark, 4(2), 82-104.
Hubbard, P, Matthews, R., Scoular, J. (2008). Regulating sex work in the EU: Prostitute women and the new spaces of exclusion. Gender, Put and Society, 15(2), 137-152.
Jonsson, S., Jakobsson, N. (2017). Is buying sex morally wrong? Comparing attitudes toward prostitution using individual-level data across eight Western European countries. Women’s Degree Around the world
Scoular, J. (2004). The “subject” of prostitution: Interpreting the discursive, symbolic and material position of sex/work in feminist theory. Feminist Idea, https://orhidi.com/en/s/models/it-sicily/palermo 5(3), 343-355.
Svedin, C. G., Jonsson, L., Kjellgren, C., Priebe, G., Akerman, I. (2012). Review of prostitution for the Sweden. Linkoping: Linkoping University Press.
Debates on currency purchases and intimacy commonly run three fighting ideas: separate spheres, “nothing-however,,” and linked existence. Brand new aggressive-worlds examine “locations tight ethical limits anywhere between field and close domain names. It condemns any intersection of money and you may intimacy since dangerously corrupting” (Zelizer, 2005, p. 22). In contrast, the fresh “nothing-but” glance at keeps one to “specific easier principle-financial, social, or governmental-indeed teaches you the proceedings” (Zelizer, 2005, p. 29). With respect to the intense-world view, there isn’t any odds of contaminants between economy and you can closeness but the “nothing-but” glance at retains one to toxic contamination can occur however, merely significantly less than bad things, particularly coercion: Prostitution are
Still, political figures continue steadily to citation regulations geared towards reducing sex functions. Just like the Ostergen (2017) points out, we could separate this new legislation/formula on several categories: abolitionism and prohi- bitionism. The reason for abolitionism should be to abolish the acquisition out of sexual services, if you find yourself prohibi- tionism seeks and also make every aspect ot sex work unlawful.
Various other goal of brand new Swedish Sex Get Act would be to prevent brand new trafficking off individuals to have reason for prostitution. The information and knowledge produced by the Swedish Federal Cops Panel will establish a decrease in trafficking, although real troubles are how to determine trafficking and you will exactly what to take on trafficking: “These issues allow it to be very hard to state that the fresh Sex Purchase Work has actually decreased trafficking within the Sweden” (Holmstrom Skilbrei, 2017, p. 93).
Bear in mind that the main goal of the Swedish statutes will be to get rid of prostitution, given that sex work is a form of an injury for females exactly who promote sexual qualities
Which goal creates a paradox of these properties organization, just who found money from the us government. The quintessential challenging an element of the regulations, people say, ‘s the 3rd-class provision, and this suppresses a 3rd party from interfering anywhere between vendors and you will consumers. The problem is that the third-team section of the legislation is additionally placed on companies. They truly became the mark of one’s law and you may, tor that it cause, bad guys on their own:
In the long run, it’s significant you to definitely Sweden are try’ing in order to export its laws and regulations abroad. Given that Swedish authorities notices what the law states in an effort to end the fresh sex trade, it’s paying money’ in order to convince different countries to adhere to brand new exact same highway:
I interviewed twenty five dudes exactly who sell sex so you can guys inside Sweden
Before speaking actually towards the interviewees towards Swedish laws, it had been needed to determine if the fresh new dudes just who sell sex when you look at the Sweden know the laws in effect about nation. Nearly all of them failed to learn about new rules otherwise had an extremely vague suggestion about any of it, while it is not difficult to find details about the new laws. When i questioned a sex personnel in which he previously located information towards Swedish legislation, he responded, “This is simply not difficult to get, it is just a google out” (Gustav, 24 yo). Yet not, most ot the new dudes We interviewed were not trying to find performing a simple Search to understand legislation of one’s nation in which they real time. Similarly, sex specialists exactly who travel across the world, plus other countries, normally failed to understand the regional regulations, as well as just weren’t finding the law of their nation out-of source possibly:
None of those twenty five guys educated any issue or issue with the police or any other public bodies. Neither performed their clients, with the better of the interviewees’ degree. Together with, such male sex workers are hardly aware ot the latest Swedish legislation or other guidelines on prostitution/sex functions. They already know that as they are dudes, they don’t chance facing people criminal charges tor selling sex for other men (or feminine). As a result, gender discrimination. Women are influenced because they are feminine, and you can the male is not affected as they are guys.